Week 10: The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn (Part 1 & 2)

Bill Condon, 2011-2012



It took exactly 47 seconds after starting this movie before I got to see the first male character take his shirt of and run around naked in the forest. The tone was set: I obviously just started my “epic” 4-hour “Twilight”-adventure! Five years after the first “Twilight” (2008) Bella is still the same overly dependent girl with low self steem. In “Breaking Dawn” the character continues to fail to develope a personality, or any character traits that make her in any way likeable. After 22 minutes, Bella finally laughs for the first time… But this wonderfull moment happens after her wedding ceremony with Edward, when the young bride lays eyes on Jacob, the lover she didn’t marry.

The first part of “Breaking Dawn” feels as if the three-minute opening credits of a regular romantic comedy have been stretched out to last two hours. In the first 45 minutes of the movie we see Bella and Edward getting married (wedding preparations not included) and having contradictory foreplay. The foreplay somehow destroys their bed and gets Bella pregnant. For the rest of the movie, Bella does what she does best: sit on a couch while shady, sparkly and clingy men take care of her.

Almost every scene in “Breaking Dawn” looks as if it was written by the drooling three year old son of Marcy and Charlie Runkle. The dialogue, the acting, the pace, even the storyline in general… it’s hard to find redeeming qualities for the “Twilight”-sequels. The second part of “Breaking Dawn” introduces an interesting element though: the fast-growing semi-vampire daughter of Bella and Edward, Renesmee. Renesmee’s introduction into the world of Stephenie Meyer might actually prove to be interesting… But we won’t find out any time soon. In the movie Renesmee is just used as a plot device to force the series into an epic climax… One that never actually happends, because one bad CGI-fight later Condon pulls the “it was all just a dream”-plot device and all the characters return home after going through a compilation of previously seen footage.

The thing that Twilight had going for me was that I didn’t know how it would end. Well – I could at least pretend I didn’t know. I read the Harry Potter-series, the Ring was obviously going to be destroyed, but Twilight had so little plot that the ending could be picked from a series of random cliches.

“Breaking Dawn” is the last movie in a series about a numb, dependant heroine, her creepy stalker and a bunch of naked guys running around in the forest. Strangely, the two-parter shows the best the sequels had to offer. Seriously – unless you want to see the story of a 108-year old virgin and a wolf that likes to mate with babies, watch “Argo” (2012) instead. That movie needs no defence. Period.


Geef een reactie

Het e-mailadres wordt niet gepubliceerd. Vereiste velden zijn gemarkeerd met *